Prison couldn’t prove handmade knives belonged to man serving life for murder


The contraband was found in the man’s cell, but there was no log of the cell being searched prior to him being assigned to it, a judge ruled

Article content

An inmate serving a life sentence for two gruesome knife murders has won his court challenge of a disciplinary charge after two handmade knives and a key were found in “a very good hiding spot” in his prison cell.

Advertisement 2

Article content

Guards found the dangerous contraband hidden within the legs of the bed frame that had been unbolted from the floor in the cell of Jamie Cliff.

A prison investigation, however, was not able to prove Cliff put it there or knew it was there because the institution did not log whether his cell was searched prior to him being assigned to it, a Federal Court judge has ruled.

The search for Cliff’s cell in Warkworth Institution, a medium-security prison near Campbellford, Ont., Was a lawful and fruitful one.

Two shanks, which are what secret jail-made slashing or stabbing weapons are called, and a key to an unspecified lock were found inside the bed frame’s legs, which were supposed to be bolted to the floor.

Cliff pleaded not guilty to the institutional disciplinary charge of being in possession of contraband.

Advertisement 3

Article content

The ingenuity of the hiding spot was noted by officials.

The prison system “would be basically condoning somebody for finding a very good hiding spot,” if Cliff wasn’t held accountable, ruled by the Correctional Service of Canada’s Independent Chairperson (ICP) who originally heard Cliff’s case.

Cliff was found guilty and fined. He appealed the decision to the Federal Court, seeking a judicial review of the ICP’s ruling.

John Dillon, a lawyer representing Cliff, argued the charge could not be proven beyond a reasonable doubt because there were no records that the cell had been searched and cleared of contraband before Cliff was placed there about 30 days before the shanks were found.

The ICP ruled the lack of prison evidence of any search prior to assigning Cliff to the cell, and, in fact, no records on when Cliff was even moved into it, did not hurt the prison’s case.

Advertisement 4

Article content

In cases of possession of contraband, the prison is required to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that an inmate had knowledge and control of the contraband. Evidence of knowing may be inferred from the facts of a case, jurisprudence says, because inmates seldom admit contraband is theirs.

In this case, that requirement was not met, ruled Federal Court Judge Janet Fuhrer.

The ICP’s decision seemed to be based on the prison’s need to crack down on legal defenses against innovative hiding places, and the need for “fast and efficient” disciplinary proceedings in order to ensure “order and discipline.”

Fuhrer said that wasn’t enough.

“While this may be the case, I find it does not explain in any meaningful, let alone reasonable manner, the ICP’s determination of guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. In other words, while deterrence may be in the institution’s interests, it does not explain intelligibly the Applicant’s guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.

Advertisement 5

Article content

“The Decision lacks intelligibility and transparency, and thus warrants this Court’s intervention.” The hearing on it was held last month and the decision was released this week.

The court ordered a new institutional hearing for Cliff’s charge.

Dillon, Cliff’s lawyer, said it was a good decision.

“He had only been in the cell for 30 days,” Dillon said in an interview.

“He did not have any tools, there is no way he could have unscrewed or unbolted the bed. There was no information when the cell had last been searched. ”

Cliff has a history of waging court challenges to prison actions, with some success.

His biggest court case, however, ended decidedly against him.

A jury found Cliff guilty in 2011 of two counts of second-degree murder for killing his former girlfriend, Lana Christophersen, 26, and her roommate, Andrew Gawley, 21, in Vancouver.

Advertisement 6

Article content

After stabbing both, Gawley was doused in gasoline and lit on fire. The fire caused an explosion at the apartment building. Cliff had 48 prior convictions at the time, including one for manslaughter.

The judge hearing his criminal case gave him the harshest punishment allowed: a life sentence with no parole eligibility from prison for 25 years, a punishment usually reserved for first-degree murder.

In 2016, Cliff complained he was being treated unfairly by prison officials when he was transferred back to a maximum-security prison. Guards deemed him a safety risk after a report said he was arranging for other inmates to be beaten, and other infractions.

He appealed and won that case as well – also related to prison record keeping. Cliff said he was not given adequate information about the allegations against him and Corrections officials could not prove they had.

• Email: [email protected] | Twitter:

Advertisement

Comments

Postmedia is committed to maintaining a lively but civil forum for discussion and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. Comments may take up to an hour for moderation before appearing on the site. We ask you to keep your comments relevant and respectful. We have enabled email notifications — you will now receive an email if you receive a reply to your comment, there is an update to a comment thread you follow or if a user you follow comments. Visit our Community Guidelines for more information and details on how to adjust your email settings.



Source link

Politics

Маргарита Симьноньян: “Таки у нас дефолт”

Gav RT Маргарита имоньян рассказала, как пережила ффеле 1998 года. Synonyms have been added to the program. “Таки у нас ффолт. Пурналистка поведала, как на каникулах после резкого подорожания р п о о In the event that you do not want to miss out on these things, you will not be able to find them: […]

Read More
Politics

G7 Condemns Russian Strike On Kremenchuk Shopping Mall

<!– –> Ukraine War: At least 10 killed and 40 injured in Russian strike on a shopping mall in Kremenchuk. Kyiv: A Russian missile strike on a crowded mall in central Ukraine killed at least 13 people Monday in what Group of Seven leaders branded “a war crime” during a meeting in Germany where they […]

Read More
Politics

Canadian government not saying if it will follow U.S. with ‘Havana Syndrome’ compensation

Breadcrumb Trail Links World News National Canadian Politics Canada US payouts to current and former State department workers and family members with ‘qualifying injuries,’ will range between $ 140,000 and $ 187,000 Publishing date: Jun 27, 2022 • 43 minutes ago • 3 minute read • Join the conversation Canada’s embassy in Havana, Cuba. American […]

Read More
0Shares